Visual Artifacts Found in SpongeBob

spongebranch said:
It’s interesting to think that SpongeBob You’re Fired premiered in Greece and Israel before the USA and had better color calibration than the USA there.
True. It really makes me wonder which of the calibrations for Seaon 9A is closer to the original animation (In other words, closer to the colors they used to animate these episodes). Do you think that the non-USA transfers are more color accurate, or the USA ones?
 
LARRY22 said:
True. It really makes me wonder which of the calibrations for Seaon 9A is closer to the original animation (In other words, closer to the colors they used to animate these episodes). Do you think that the non-USA transfers are more color accurate, or the USA ones?
The non-USA transfers are more color accurate. Just saw SpongeBob You're Fired air last night and the color calibration was so bad that even the HD widescreen intro had grayish whites.
 
Re-Hydrated Sponge said:
Pretty sure the one on the top was drawn by Carson Kugler ,while the bottom one was drawn either by Sherm Cohen or Erik Wiese
Sadly, nowadays every episode looks the same regardless of who directed

Sent from my LG-M327 using Tapatalk
 
**PLEASE PUT YOUR PICTURES IN SPOILERS TO SPEED UP THE PAGE LOADS**

or

**PLEASE USE THE SBMANIA PICTURE GALLERY TO POST PICS**
 
Anyone notice how the VHS effect can be so bad, it can distort the picture to the point where a digitally animated show looks like it's cel animated. I got a headache last night watching an early season 3 episode of Dexter's Lab because I was trying to figure out whether or not the episode used digital ink and paint or cel animation. The VHS effect was that bad.
 
Original Raw and Uncut said:
or be patient
When the page load times out because of the load time, it's a problem for other users. :)
 
Original Raw and Uncut said:
I think we should talk about visual artifacts in other shows too
Okay, I can do that. Has anyone ever noticed how bad the rainbow artifact is on the door in the opening sequence of Courage the Cowardly Dog? Weirdly enough, some episodes it's not even there, but when it IS there, it's so noticeable it's almost distracting from what's actually going on. I apologize in advance for the crappy quality screenshot. This episode was recorded through the TV mode on Windows Media Center. lol

rpVKCFs.png
 
ThatSkynyrdKid70 said:
Okay, I can do that. Has anyone ever noticed how bad the rainbow artifact is on the door in the opening sequence of Courage the Cowardly Dog? Weirdly enough, some episodes it's not even there, but when it IS there, it's so noticeable it's almost distracting from what's actually going on. I apologize in advance for the crappy quality screenshot. This episode was recorded through the TV mode on Windows Media Center. lol

rpVKCFs.png

Yeah, the VHS effect is pretty distracting. A few courage episodes have over saturated colors too.

Here's something I've noticed about the first few episodes of Season 3 of Dexter's Lab. The coloring is extremely dull, the dot crawl distorts the picture so bad, it's hard to tell what animation technique was used to make the episodes. The VHS effect is atrocious in the episode "Copping an Attidue/A Failed Lab Expeirement/The Granddaddy of all Invetions. Does anyone think that the first few episodes of the third season may have been cel animated only with more touch ups than seasons one and two, or are my eyes playing tricks on me. What do you guys think. Or is it because of the bad VHS effect. Early-00's Rugrats also has VHS effect episodes that look so bad, I can't differentiate the difference between cel and digital. Anyways, the color scheme in the first few Savino episodes of Dexter's Lab have a color scheme similar to season 1 of Spongebob, although they lack the same visual artifacts that were visible in Genndy's version of the show. These aired in 2001 by the way. I was watching the episode "The Granddaddy of All Inventions", and I couldn't help but to notice that VHS effect was so bad, it was indistinguishable to the cel animated movie Ego Trip. Here are some screenshots from the episode, and you'll see what I mean when I say it's hard to tell whether or not this is digital or cel:

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.49.31 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.47.10 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.47.16 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.48.37 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.48.34 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.48.53 PM.png

Screenshot 2018-11-25 at 8.47.50 PM.png


What do you guys think, was this cel, or digital?
 
Original Raw and Uncut said:
Yeah, the VHS effect is pretty distracting. A few courage episodes have over saturated colors too.

Here's something I've noticed about the first few episodes of Season 3 of Dexter's Lab. The coloring is extremely dull, the dot crawl distorts the picture so bad, it's hard to tell what animation technique was used to make the episodes. The VHS effect is atrocious in the episode "Copping an Attidue/A Failed Lab Expeirement/The Granddaddy of all Invetions. Does anyone think that the first few episodes of the third season may have been cel animated only with more touch ups than seasons one and two, or are my eyes playing tricks on me. What do you guys think. Or is it because of the bad VHS effect. Early-00's Rugrats also has VHS effect episodes that look so bad, I can't differentiate the difference between cel and digital. Anyways, the color scheme in the first few Savino episodes of Dexter's Lab have a color scheme similar to season 1 of Spongebob, although they lack the same visual artifacts that were visible in Genndy's version of the show. These aired in 2001 by the way. I was watching the episode "The Granddaddy of All Inventions", and I couldn't help but to notice that VHS effect was so bad, it was indistinguishable to the cel animated movie Ego Trip. Here are some screenshots from the episode, and you'll see what I mean when I say it's hard to tell whether or not this is digital or cel:



What do you guys think, was this cel, or digital?
Looks to me like cel animation.
 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsoS5rppJ6Q
Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy III with dot crawl on Nickelodeon Greece, however if you look closely, the dot crawl patterns look different than on the Season 2 DVD, which further proves that the raw international prints have no dot crawl. (at least this didn't before the Greek channel telecined it)
 
ThatSkynyrdKid70 said:
Looks to me like cel animation.
It's digital ink and paint. The art is the same as every other season 3-4 episode, the only difference is the dull color. animation. These early season 3 episodes, although have dull paint-like coloring, are still animated by electronic means. The outlines in these episodes are straight and geometrical, rather than being wobbly and having the same thickness. Each line having an equal level of thickness can only be achieved through cel animation. They also lack the cel shadows wobbliness that is present in S1-S2 and Ego Trip. The reason why these episodes look very dull is because they're bad copies. The international prints for Dexter's Lab lack the VHS effect, making the episodes look the way they're animated. Same goes for the first two seasons of the Venture Bros, they look cel animated because they have bad prints, but they're digitally animated. Also the same case with the show Clone High, which uses digital ink and paint, but the broadcast versions look cel animated.

WARNING: The Clone High Clips can get a bit raunchy, I'm using these as a demonstration on how the VHS effect can distort the picture, tricking the audience by making digitally animated shows look cel animated. Watch at your own risk

For Clone High (Broadcast Version):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FOZ0k0xPzdo

Notice how the broadcast tape looks cel animated


Clone High (DVD print):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wXXvaOTj-M&index=13&list=PLXblBYbO4aPbReuXAJtkQ-OgSVcdH9vj4
Now, the DVD verison looks like it's digital ink and paint.

This is an issue with many early-00's shows that were electronically colored. I think it had to do with calibration issues converting the computer files on to the flatbeds, so they could be aired on television. Most shows switched to digital ink and paint before studios stopped using flatbeds, which explains why some episodes in Season 2 of Spongebob look cel animated, even though they're digital ink and paint. Same goes for Rugrats, which went digital around 2000. When studios begun to digitally broadcast their shows, the VHS effect became less of an issue. No longer forcing the staff to transfer episodes using composite. The best way to differentiate between cel animation and digital ink and paint, is by the way the characters move, not they way they're colored.
 
Nickelodeon USA's airing of the SpongeBob episodes "Don't Look Now/Séance Schmeance" strangely had fixed color calibration from Amazon Instant Video/non-USA prints when they aired on Nick 2 today. (they didn't have the fixed color calibration on the regular Nick though)
 
Apparently, nick@nite had a cropping error the other night. They accidentally aired a season six episode in Widescreen:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MErQR1zv3yg
 
Original Raw and Uncut said:
Apparently, nick@nite had a cropping error the other night. They accidentally aired a season six episode in Widescreen:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MErQR1zv3yg
that actually was earlier this month, not last night.

I wonder how every episode looks on the Season 9 DVD.
 
LARRY22 said:
I think the images on this site are from the Season 9 DVD, but I'm not too sure.
it was stated in the SBMania updates thread that the pics from SpongeBob You're Fired and some other Season 9a episodes were from iTunes.
 
Back
Top