Pinned thread Episode or Episode

[TheYellowSponge101]

Roller Cowards

The Secret Box or Naughty Nautical Neighbors

 

[SpongyMaterial]

The Secret Box

Driven to Tears or Mrs. Puff, You're Fired?

 

[SpongeShine]

Mrs. Puff, You're Fired

Jellyfish Hunter or Jellyfish jam?

 

[Ugly Barnacle]

Jellyfish Jam

Boating School or Fools in April

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Fools in April

New Digs or New Leaf?

 

[Ugly Barnacle]

New Digs

Krusty Krushers or Overbooked

 

[Patrick NotStar]

Hmm, Overbooked.

Chocolate With Nuts or The Graveyard Shift?

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Chocolate with Nuts

Sandy, SpongeBob, and the Worm or Wormy?

 

[Ugly Barnacle]

Wormy

Pickles or SpongeGuard on Duty

 

[Jibbix]

Spongeguard On Duty.

Kracked Krabs Or Shell Of A Man? They're pretty much the same episode with minor twists.

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Kracked Krabs

Dunces and Dragons or Ugh?

 

[Ugly Barnacle]

Dunces and Dragons..Ugh is too boring!

Hooky or Clams?

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Clams

I'm With Stupid or Big Sister Sam?

 

[Ugly Barnacle]

I'm With Stupid, without a doubt!

Truth or Square or Friend or Foe?

 

[GoodNoodle]

I like them about the same, but I'll pick Truth or Square.
Sentimental Sponge or Squidward's School for Grown-Ups?

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Sentimental Sponge

Karate Choppers or The Way of the Sponge?

 

[GoodNoodle]

Karate Choppers
This one's REALLY hard:
The Splinter or Pet or Pests?

 

[SpongyMaterial]

Pet or Pests (I don't think these episodes are gross)

Patty Hype or Fear of a Krabby Patty?

 

[TheYellowSponge101]

Fear of a Krabby Patty

Graveyard Shift or Scaredy Pants

 

[GoodNoodle]

Graveyard Shift!
Plankton! or Boating School?