Rate (Good, Meh, Bad) of all Episodes per Season

[Master WhoBruh]

i know this is a bit off-topic since we're already at season 6,but i've just finished watching season 3,here are my ratings.

The Algae's Always Greener-WONDERFUL



SpongeGuard on Duty-WONDERFUL

Club SpongeBob-Good

My Pretty Seahorse-Great

Just One Bite-WONDERFUL

The Bully-Great

Nasty Patty-WONDERFUL

Idiot Box-WONDERFUL

Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy IV-Good

Doing Time-WONDERFUL

Snowball Effect-Great

One Krabs Trash-WONDERFUL

As Seen on TV-WONDERFUL

Can You Spare a Dime?-WONDERFUL

No Weenies Allowed-WONDERFUL

Squilliam Returns-Great

Krab Borg-WONDERFUL

Rock-a-Bye Bivalve-WONDERFUL

Wet Painters-WONDERFUL

Krusty Krab Training Video-WONDERFUL

Party Pooper Pants-WONDERFUL (please don't kill me)

Chocolate with Nuts-WONDERFUL

Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy V-WONDERFUL

New Student Starfish-WONDERFUL

Clams-WONDERFUL

Ugh-Good

The Great Snail Race-ATROCIOUS

Mid-Life Crustacean-Great

Born Again Krabs-Tolerable

I Had an Accident-Good

Krabby Land-Good

The Camping Episode-WONDERFUL

Missing Identity-WONDERFUL

Plankton's Army-WONDERFUL

The Sponge Who Could Fly-ATROCIOUS

SpongeBob Meets the Strangler-WONDERFUL

Pranks a Lot-Great


23 wonderful (WOW) (2nd favorite season)
6 great
4 good
1 tolerable
0 bad
2 atrocious

i'll post season 2(i've only got about 3 more episodes to watch) and season 4(i'm halfway through this season) later.

You didn't rate Snowball Effect WONDERFUL? Youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[SpongyDevotee]

Don't worry. I don't mind The Inmates of Summer or get why it's suddenly getting a lot of hate. Lee Ermey is pretty good in it.

I think I'll be able to understand why, once I get to More_SpongeBob_Sandy's post. And yeah, Lee Ermey is the best at voicing military characters. For example, he plays the toy army men in Toy Story.

 

[Amphitrite]

I hated Banned in Bikini Bottom, because of the songs, poorly executed plot, and unlikable characters. Miss Gristlepuss is easily one of, if not, the worst one-time character in SpongeBob history.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

You didn't rate Snowball Effect WONDERFUL? Youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It's okay. He rated it Great. (shrugs)

If you think the episode is WONDERFUL, then that's good. ^_^ But if he thinks that it's Great, then that's also good.

 

[More]

Well, I'll put a complete list of episodes that are either meh (HM or Weak) or Bad (Moderate, Severe, or Bottom 10) The total bad episodes- about 60.

Spoiler

HMs- (this is not a complete list of them, tell me if I missed anything)

Spoiler

Reef Blower
Opposite Day
The Chaperone
Bossy Boots
Squid on Strike
As Seen on TV
Doing Time
Whale of a Birthday
The Gift of Gum
The Krusty Plate
Blackened Sponge
Nautical Novice
Plankton's Regular
SpongeBob vs the Big One
Krusty Krushers
Ditchin'
The Curse of the Hex
Fiasco!
Seance Shmeance (sorry wasn't all that impressed)

1. I Was a Teenage Gary
2. Squeaky Boots
3. Neptune's Spatula
4. Dumped
5. I'm With Stupid
6. Artist Unknown
7. Party Pooper Pants
8. The Sponge Who Could Fly
9. Good Neighbors
10. Funny Pants
11. All That Glitters
12. The Thing
13. Squid Wood
14. The Best Day Ever!
15. The Original Fry Cook
16. Night Light
17. Waiting
18. Fungus Among Us
19. Boat Smarts
20. Good 'Ol Whatshisname
21. To Love a Patty
22. Atlantis SquarePantis
23. Pat No Pay
24. BlackJack
25. The Inmates of Summer
26. To Save a Squirrel
27. "What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?"
28. SpongeHenge
29. Stanley S. SquarePants
30. House Fancy
31. Penny Foolish
32. Gone
33. The Splinter
34. Slide Whistle Stooges
35. Sun Bleached
36. Giant Squidward
37. Boating Buddies
38. The Krabby Kronicle
39. Grooming Gary
40. Porous Pockets
41. Choir Boys
42. The Card
43. Cephalopod Lodge
44. Squid's Visit
45. To SquarePants or NOT to SquarePants
46. ShuffleBoarding
47. Professor Squidward
48. Pet or Pests
49. Gullible Pants
50. No Hat for Pat
51. Pineapple Fever
52. Chum Caverns
53. The Clash of Triton
54. Tentacle-Vision
55. I Heart Dancing
56. Growth Spout
57. Stuck in the Wringer
58. Someone's in the Kitchen with Sandy
59. Greasy Buffoons
60. Model Sponge
61. Keep Bikini Bottom Beautiful
62. A Pal for Gary
63. Yours, Mine and Mine
64, Kracked Krabs
65. SpongeBob's Last Stand
66. A Day Without Tears
67. Summer Job
68. One Coarse Meal
69. The Play's the Ting
70. Rodeo Daze
71. Gramma's Secret Recipe
72. The Cent of Money
73. The Main Drain
74. ThrenchBillies
75. Sponge-Cano!
76. The Great Patty Caper
77. Hide and Then What Happens?
78. Krusty Dogs
79. New Fish in Town
80. Big Sister Sam
81. Drive Thru
82. A Friendly Game
83. Sentimental Sponge
84. Squidward's School for Grown-Ups
85. The Googly Artiste
86. Mr Krabs Takes a Vacation
87. Barnacle Face
88. Pet Sitter Pat
89. Smoothe Jazz at Bikini Bottom
90. Bubble Troubles
91. Bubble Buddy Returns
92. Restraining SpongeBob
93. InSPONGEiac
94. Face Freeze
95. Demoliton Doofus
96. For Here or To Go
97. Move It or Lose It
98. Squid Baby
99. Little Yellow Book
100. SpongeBob You're Fired (Though I know I should hate it, I just don't)

101. SpaceBob InvaderPants (It only sounds bad on it's cover, but we'll never know)

 

[SpongyDevotee]

I hated Banned in Bikini Bottom, because of the songs, poorly executed plot, and unlikable characters. Miss Gristlepuss is easily one of, if not, the worst one-time character in SpongeBob history.

What's so bad about the songs?! I also thought that the plot was pretty good. And I would say that the only unlikable charcters were Miss Gristlepuss, her "sisters", and Al. And she is the ANTAGONIST, so she's kinda supposed to be unlikable and cruel. And she's reborn at the end by the power of Krabby Patties, sort of like Squidward is in Just One Bite.

 

[Amphitrite]

What's so bad about the songs?! I also thought that the plot was pretty good. And I would say that the only unlikable charcters were Miss Gristlepuss, her "sisters", and Al. And she is the ANTAGONIST, so she's kinda supposed to be unlikable and cruel. And she's reborn at the end by the power of Krabby Patties, sort of like Squidward is in Just One Bite.

That's the problem. She was too unlikable. The songs were annoying, too. The other characters were no better.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

Well, I'll put a complete list of episodes that are either meh (HM or Weak) or Bad (Moderate, Severe, or Bottom 10) The total bad episodes- 60.

Spoiler

HMs-

Spoiler

Reef Blower
Opposite Day
The Chaperone
Bossy Boots
Squid on Strike
As Seen on TV
Doing Time
Whale of a Birthday
The Gift of Gum
The Krusty Plate
Blackened Sponge
Nautical Novice
Plankton's Regular
SpongeBob vs the Big One
Krusty Krushers
Ditchin'
The Curse of the Hex
Fiasco!
Seance Shmeance (sorry wasn't all that impressed)

1. I Was a Teenage Gary
2. Squeaky Boots
3. Neptune's Spatula
4. Dumped
5. I'm With Stupid
6. Artist Unknown
7. Party Pooper Pants
8. The Sponge Who Could Fly
9. Good Neighbors
10. Funny Pants
11. All That Glitters
12. The Thing
13. Squid Wood
14. The Best Day Ever!
15. The Original Fry Cook
16. Night Light
17. Waiting
18. Fungus Among Us
19. Boat Smarts
20. Good 'Ol Whatshisname
21. To Love a Patty
22. Atlantis SquarePantis
23. Pat No Pay
24. BlackJack
25. The Inmates of Summer
26. To Save a Squirrel
27. "What Ever Happened to SpongeBob?"
28. SpongeHenge
29. Stanley S. SquarePants
30. House Fancy
31. Penny Foolish
32. Gone
33. The Splinter
34. Slide Whistle Stooges
35. Sun Bleached
36. Giant Squidward
37. Boating Buddies
38. The Krabby Kronicle
39. Grooming Gary
40. Porous Pockets
41. Choir Boys
42. The Card
43. Cephalopod Lodge
44. Squid's Visit
45. To SquarePants or NOT to SquarePants
46. ShuffleBoarding
47. Professor Squidward
48. Pet or Pests
49. Gullible Pants
50. No Hat for Pat
51. Pineapple Fever
52. Chum Caverns
53. The Clash of Triton
54. Tentacle-Vision
55. I Heart Dancing
56. Growth Spout
57. Stuck in the Wringer
58. Someone's in the Kitchen with Sandy
59. Greasy Buffoons
60. Model Sponge
61. Keep Bikini Bottom Beautiful
62. A Pal for Gary
63. Yours, Mine and Mine
64, Kracked Krabs
65. SpongeBob's Last Stand
66. A Day Without Tears
67. Summer Job
68. One Coarse Meal
69. The Play's the Ting
70. Rodeo Daze
71. Gramma's Secret Recipe
72. The Cent of Money
73. The Main Drain
74. ThrenchBillies
75. Sponge-Cano!
76. The Great Patty Caper
77. Hide and Then What Happens?
78. Krusty Dogs
79. New Fish in Town
80. Big Sister Sam
81. Drive Thru
82. A Friendly Game
83. Sentimental Sponge
84. Squidward's School for Grown-Ups
85. The Googly Artiste
86. Mr Krabs Takes a Vacation
87. Barnacle Face
88. Pet Sitter Pat
89. Smoothe Jazz at Bikini Bottom
90. Bubble Troubles
91. Bubble Buddy Returns
92. Restraining SpongeBob
93. InSPONGEiac
94. Face Freeze
95. Demoliton Doofus
96. For Here or To Go
97. Move It or Lose It
98. Squid Baby
99. Little Yellow Book
100. SpongeBob You're Fired (Though I know I should hate it, I just don't)

101. SpaceBob InvaderPants (It only sounds bad on it's cover, but we'll never know)

I'll go through this entire list later, but I'll go through the HMs right now.

I disagree with these:

HMs-
The Chaperone
As Seen on TV
Whale of a Birthday (I thought you LOVED the episode?!)
The Gift of Gum (I'm sorry, but I honestly LOVE this episode to death! Oh wait, death is such a negative connotation.)
The Krusty Plate
Nautical Novice
Plankton's Regular
Ditchin'
Seance Shmeance (sorry wasn't all that impressed) (I should rewatch it)

 

[More]

I'll go through this entire list later, but I'll go through the HMs right now.

I disagree with these:

HMs-
The Chaperone
As Seen on TV
Whale of a Birthday (I thought you LOVED the episode?!)
The Gift of Gum (I'm sorry, but I honestly LOVE this episode to death! Oh wait, death is such a negative connotation.)
The Krusty Plate
Nautical Novice
Plankton's Regular
Ditchin'
Seance Shmeance (sorry wasn't all that impressed) (I should rewatch it)

I did love WoaB, but after hearing what PGR had to say about the episode, I'm just indifferent to it now. But I also changed Karate Island to an Amazing after rewatching it. All those episodes I'm just indifferent to. I'm also close indifferent to the "weak" episodes, or they may be debatable episodes that could be bad or good.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

That's the problem. She was too unlikable. The songs were annoying, too. The other characters were no better.

Well, she was kinda supposed to be unlikable to be an antagonist.

And I never thought that the songs were annoying at all. What's so annoying about SpongeBob singing about Krabby Patties?! The songs were fun. I liked them.

What's wrong with the other characters in this episode?

By the way, I found MANY parts of this episode hilarious! ^_^

 

[Master WhoBruh]

I find the song in BIBB a little annoying TBH. I don't hate BIBB and yes, Miss Gristlepuss is supposed to be the antagonist but the reasons why I don't like this episode are poorly executed plot, the song and not too much humor. Actually BIBB has a good premise, banning Krusty Krab is a great idea for a 100th episode but Miss Gristlepuss bans Krusty Krab because Krabby Patties are fun and delicious. SERIOUSLY, Krusty Krab is banned because of this? That's the problem with Miss Gristlepuss. Food in the restaurants being fun and delicious shouldn't even be considered as the reasons of restaurants getting banned. Some restauants get banned because It isn't a healty place to eat or the delicious or gross foods' secret ingredients are so dangerous for people. If we eat harmless delicious food, what's the problem with eating it? We go to the restaurants, so we can eat delicous food. If harmless delicious foods gets banned, we're gong to eat the foods that taste like garbage until we die? Miss Gristlepuss is antagonist but not in a good way and she didn't know how to live her life until she ate a Krabby Patty. I'm not against the rest of the episode though. The episode at least had some funny moments but the episode isn't really fun to watch and the plot is executed poorly.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

I did love WoaB, but after hearing what PGR had to say about the episode, I'm just indifferent to it now. But I also changed Karate Island to an Amazing after rewatching it. All those episodes I'm just indifferent to. I'm also close indifferent to the "weak" episodes.

Well, who cares if Pieguyrulz had a different opinion than you? I mean, you loved the episode, so I think that it's unfortunate that someone else made you dislike it. =/ But if you truly feel that way about the episode now, then that's fine. I still love it though, regardless of what Pieguyrulz said. And also, Mr. Krabs didn't buy Pearl's Flipper Slippers in Squeaky Boots. But did Pieguyrulz complain about that?! No! He even gave that episode a Good. But he complains about Mr. Krabs not buying Pearl some presents in Whale of a Birthday, even though Mr. Krabs did the same exact thing in Squeaky Boots.

 

[More]

Well, who cares if Pieguyrulz had a different opinion than you? I mean, you loved the episode, so I think that it's unfortunate that someone else made you dislike it. =/ But if you truly feel that way about the episode now, then that's fine. I still love it though, regardless of what Pieguyrulz said. And also, Mr. Krabs didn't buy Pearl's Flipper Slippers in Squeaky Boots. But did Pieguyrulz complain about that?! No! He even gave that episode a Good. But he complains about Mr. Krabs not buying Pearl some presents in Whale of a Birthday, even though Mr. Krabs did the same exact thing in Squeaky Boots.

Hey, at least he DID buy a present in Squeaky Boots. Besides, Pearl was only like ten, and I think 16 is a much bigger deal. And also in SB, he attempted to throw a party, here he completely forgot. And I think he ended up buying the slippers in the end. In the latter, SpongeBob bought all the stuff.


But even though he did have good points, I still can't dislike the episode.


I didn't change all of my ratings from him. I definitely disagreed with episodes like New Leaf and Hocus Pocus being ScumBob.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

Hey, at least he DID buy a present in Squeaky Boots. Besides, Pearl was only like ten, and I think 16 is a much bigger deal.


But even though he did have good points, I still can't dislike the episode.

Yeah, and that "present" that he bought Pearl was some cra*py boots that were on sale, and probably only costed like $1 or something. I mean, why would Pearl want to wear some hideous, old people boots?!

And hey, at least Mr. Krabs DID make a party for Pearl in Whale of a Birthday.

Also, I don't think Pearl was 10 in Squeaky Boots. For example, she was in middle school in The Chaperone, and both of these episodes are Season 1.

Okay, I'm glad you don't DISLIKE the episode. But still, I'm kind of upset to see that for an episode that you LOVED, you now like it a lot less. =/

I mean, I would NEVER stop loving episodes like Rock-a-Bye Bivalve, New Digs, and Picture Day. I am always ready to defend those episodes and my opinions for them, regardless of anything.

 

[More]

Yeah, and that "present" that he bought Pearl was some cra*py boots that were on sale, and probably only costed like $1 or something. I mean, why would Pearl want to wear some hideous, old people boots?!

And hey, at least Mr. Krabs DID make a party for Pearl.

Also, I don't think Pearl was 10 in Squeaky Boots. For example, she was in middle school in The Chaperone, and both of these episodes are Season 1.

Okay, I'm glad you don't DISLIKE the episode. But still, I'm kind of upset to see that for an episode that you LOVED, you now like it a lot less. =/

I mean, I would NEVER stop loving episodes like Rock-a-Bye Bivalve, New Digs, and Picture Day. I am always ready to defend those episodes and my opinions for them, regardless of anything.

And I always would defend A LOT of episodes, including KKTV, CWN, and WYW. Just some are more vulnerable than others as I didn't grow on them as much.


Maybe we should stop talking about this now.

 

[SpongyDevotee]

And also in SB, he attempted to throw a party, here he completely forgot. And I think he ended up buying the slippers in the end. In the latter, SpongeBob bought all the stuff.

I didn't change all of my ratings from him. I definitely disagreed with episodes like New Leaf and Hocus Pocus being ScumBob.

He DID throw a party in Whale of a Birthday though. And in Squeaky Boots, the party seemed even lamer. At least Mr. Krabs actually TRIED in Whale of a Birthday. Yeah, he did buy Pearl those slippers, which was nice. (By the way, I like Squeaky Boots.) But, Mr. Krabs was the one who TOLD SpongeBob to buy her presents in Whale of a Birthday!

And what a relief! I thought you would agree with EVERYTHING Pieguyrulz said. I'm so glad that you still love New Leaf and Hocus Pocus. ^_^ Just so you know, I agreed with all 18 of his Goods, but I disagreed with a lot of his Mehs and Bads. I'm also thinking of making a topic of discussing my opinions for what Pieguyrulz said about each episode and how I think he rated them fairly or unfairly.

And I always would defend A LOT of episodes, including KKTV, CWN, and WYW. Just some are more vulnerable than others as I didn't grow on them as much.


Maybe we should stop talking about this now.

Yeah, I guess. I can tell that you would always love episodes like Krusty Krab Training Video, and that's good. ^_^ And okay, I can kind of see your point, but still.

And since it is your wish to stop talking about this, then okay. :)

 

[Master WhoBruh]

He DID throw a party in Whale of a Birthday though. And in Squeaky Boots, the party seemed even lamer. At least Mr. Krabs actually TRIED in Whale of a Birthday. Yeah, he did buy Pearl those slippers, which was nice. (By the way, I like Squeaky Boots.) But, Mr. Krabs was the one who TOLD SpongeBob to buy her presents in Whale of a Birthday!

And what a relief! I thought you would agree with EVERYTHING Pieguyrulz said. I'm so glad that you still love New Leaf and Hocus Pocus. ^_^ Just so you know, I agreed with all 18 of his Goods, but I disagreed with a lot of his Mehs and Bads. I'm also thinking of making a topic of discussing my opinions for what Pieguyrulz said about each episode and how I think he rated them fairly or unfairly.



Yeah, I guess. I can tell that you would always love episodes like Krusty Krab Training Video, and that's good. ^_^ And okay, I can kind of see your point, but still.

And since it is your wish to stop talking about this, then okay. :)

I still love episodes that PIEGUYRULZ considered as bad or meh episodes like Whale of the Birthday, Squidward the Unfriendly Ghost, Have You Seen This Snail, I Was a Teenage Gary, Hocus Pocus, etc and I barely even changed my opinions about them. I still like episodes such as Pet Sitter Pat, Tentacle Vision, You Don't Know Sponge, Squid Baby, Demolotion Doofus, Squid Wood, Boat Smarts, no matter what many people said bad thing about them. I only change my opinions about the episodes, If I don't enjoy watching them again or see their flaws, when I watch these episodes again. (Choir Boys, SpongeBob You're Fired, etc)

 

[Amphitrite]

I still love episodes that PIEGUYRULZ considered as bad or meh episodes like Whale of the Birthday, Squidward the Unfriendly Ghost, Have You Seen This Snail, I Was a Teenage Gary, Hocus Pocus, etc and I barely even changed my opinions about them. I still like episodes such as Pet Sitter Pat, Tentacle Vision, You Don't Know Sponge, Squid Baby, Demolotion Doofus, Squid Wood, Boat Smarts, no matter what many people said bad thing about them. I only change my opinions about the episodes, If I don't enjoy watching them again or see their flaws, when I watch these episodes again. (Choir Boys, SpongeBob You're Fired, etc)

Just like how I hate Sandy's Rocket. Some members pointed out the positives in that episode, but I still hate it and always will.

 

[Master WhoBruh]

Just like how I hate Sandy's Rocket. Some members pointed out the positives in that episode, but I still hate it and always will.

And I don't like Rule of Dumb, no matter what people said good things about this episode. I watched the episode again yesterday and I still don't like it. It's just too low on humor and Patrick bothered me a lot.

 

[AngryKoopa2002]

I tried to find it, but I seriously couldn't. I checked all over your profile, but it wasn't there.

I did find this link to it though: http://www.sbmania.net/forums/blog/172/entry-961-adventure-time-season-1-review/

But when I clicked on it, it wouldn't let me see it, and an Error Message was on there that said: [#10685] You are not authorised to view this page

I'm really sorry though. If I knew where to find it and how to actually see the topic, I would have definitely commented and gave you feeback. =/

That was the one. Try again.