I think this is a pretty underrated episode. It's comedy is really good, it's not a Squidward torture episode like many of the episodes are after it. Everyone gets their comeuppance in the end. Also, while the episode does focus on Mr. Krabs's cheapness, it doesn't feel forced or extreme. It's a pretty neat concept for the show.
Today we're here with an old review of "The Lost Mattress", a review I plan to update thoroughly, as my opinions have grown since 2018. I've been busy doing work and recording my YouTube reviews today, which is why this review is coming in relatively later than usual.
I still stand by my old assessment that this is a pretty underrated episode, which is such a shame, because I really like "The Lost Mattress" lol. I like the beginning shot of this episode being of Big Ben, mostly because it immediately makes you question what the H you're watching. But then of course the camera pans out to show that it's just Squidward's watch. Speaking of liking the beginning of this episode, I like how Squidward just walks into the doors, and I like SpongeBob sitting outside the locked Krusty Krab freaking out. Sometimes SpongeBob is just a little weirdo and that's okay! Then we get a shot that reminds me of "Squid on Strike", which I appreciate. Also, did anyone else notice that the Krusty Krab in this part of the episode doesn't have the pavement surrounding it? Very interesting lol. I wonder why that happened? It keeps sticking out to me.
This first part of the episode also has Mr. Krabs acting very much like a dad to SpongeBob with that whole lashing out in pain and then having to take it back deal. You know I'll always take my fatherly Mr. Krabs crumbs so of course I had to point this out. And then of course SpongeBob is his very caring self, being worried for Mr. Krabs. Squidward's got some good snarky lines in here too. I like how SpongeBob's like "you'll warm up to the idea".
Patrick enters this episode very randomly yet unceremoniously. Nothing to complain about there, I just like how without fanfare it is. The bit at the mattress store is one of the more well-known parts of this episode, which is very interesting to me because Patrick's gross underestimation is not outrageously funny, but I think it's often used as a reaction meme so that's probably why it's more well-known. I like the montage of the best friends at the montage store, some of those mattresses looked really nice let's be real. I also like how childish SpongeBob and Patrick are in this episode. It's nothing crazy, but it toes the line I love to talk about very well. And the making a card thing is just so cute. I like that Squidward gets involved to, just like SpongeBob said he would (of course he has less than honest intentions). I like that Patrick calls him out on it too. Patrick and Squidward have that interesting dynamic sometimes, where SpongeBob is more of the connection between them than anything, and so Patrick will call Squidward out for doing some rude stuff. It doesn't happen very often, but it has happened, and I think it's neat.
This episode is another one of those episodes with two distinct segments, though in this case we do get a pretty lengthy transition scene between the first segment and the second. And man is this transition scene fun, seeing Mr. Krabs get more and more irate as he hears about what happened to his mattress. And we get a nice bit of early universal justice as he pounces on Squidward for hauling his money-filled mattress in the dump. The scene is perfectly dramatic and I love it. I love the bit with Mr. Krabs waking up for the card, only to faint again.
This episode is really filled with some brilliant jokes. Like the part where the cop is in the room and Squidward has to stop himself from saying that he's going to murder SpongeBob. Or, the more well-known entirety of the B-plot/side gag of Mr. Krabs at the hospital while Squidward, Patrick, and SpongeBob retrieve his mattress at the dump. This is definitely one of my favorite jokes in this whole show (link to it
here). First we got Mr. Krabs being forced out of the room because he can't afford it, but then becoming an eyesore, so just being forced outside. The funeral music and Mr. Krabs' groans are just amazing and sell the whole thing along with the line deliveries. What a perfect representation of the United States Healthcare System. I'm not even going to strikethrough that one, that's exactly what it is. This is the same show that made "Squid On Strike", this is tame compared to the political commentary that was that entire episode.
As for SpongeBob, Squidward, and Patrick's segment, it may not be as funny as this lengthy joke, but it's still pretty enjoyable. We've got some great slapstick here, as well as more universal justice being doled out to Squidward, which is deserved. And it's not egregious either. I like how Mr. Krabs manages to burst back onto the scene and "defend his territory", so to speak. I love SpongeBob's "run Mr. Krabs! Run like you're not in a coma!" line. And then of course we get a lovely stinger at the end, with the worm landing in Squidward's arms and him having to run away.
Real quick, I just wanted to shout out the beautiful backgrounds in this episode. I love the exterior of the hospital at night, and the dump looks pretty cool too. And then when morning comes around we get those beautiful blue, greens, and yellows that remind me of "Home Sweet Pineapple" or "Rock-A-Bye Bivalve". Just gorgeous as always.
"The Lost Mattress" is a really enjoyable episode with some clever and hilarious gags. It's also interesting that this episode manages to have a B-plot for a good portion of it, as that's not a usual occurrence in
SpongeBob SquarePants. Yeah the B-plot is really like a side-gag more than anything, but it still counts to me. This episode is definitely better in its second half than its first, but I still enjoy all of it through and through. A worthy addition to my "Amazing" tier.
Episode Tier: Amazing
Episode Score: 9.2/10