Oh I remember this one, this was that episode that was taken way too seriously by “critics”, right? Yeah…good times, good times. Other than that little tidbit, this isn’t an episode I’ve ever felt too strongly about, other than being annoyed by Patrick. So I wonder if this is still going to hold up today.
I suppose the greatest sin of this episode is that it’s kind of boring from the outset. An episode all about Squidward’s art being critiqued is not exactly interesting content. And when an episode begins with the track
Tip Toe Through the Seaweed, I already feel bored (even if the track is good on its own, just used in the most boring moments). Very few of the jokes in this episode land well, and the rest of it is just kind of middling. It does just barely enough to keep me engaged, but I’m still not happy.
The second big sin of the episode, which isn’t actually very much of a sin, is that it continues the unfortunate trend of making Patrick a jerkwad for absolutely no reason. Now, to be very fair, Patrick is hardly that much of a jerk in this episode. He really only has like…2 moments. So his jerkness is actually way overblown. BUT, I don’t really like Patrick here even with this in mind. I’m kinda just bored of him, and apathy is not a thing I want to feel about anything in this show. I fear I’m being too harsh on Patrick, being too influenced by old reviews circa like 10 years ago, but I feel the way I feel, you know?
This episode does have its good moments though. Like the part with the critic and Squidward was pretty funny, especially when he’s all like “I’m a critic; I don’t make things, I judge things.” Like that’s very clearly a dig at the actual critics of the world, and I love it. It makes me think of that one little review and it so very missed the point—this episode is about Rotten Tomatoes type critics, not little nobody YouTubers like let’s be serious. Am I being mean? I don’t care lol because it’s fun. Anyway, the guy who is clearly addicted to art is pretty funny too. And the interaction between SpongeBob and Squidward about his “gambling problem” is hilarious. I also liked when Mr. Krabs finds out that Patrick’s selling his art in the Krusty Krab, it was funny. And I know I’ve said this before, but I like when this crustacean wins by being a horrible cheap person LMAO. It’s just enjoyable.
I suppose I should also make mention of how “The Googly Artist” is similar to “Artist Unknown”. I actually don’t think the episodes are
that similar, definitely not enough to warrant calling this one a rip-off, especially because the messages of the two episodes are, in my eyes, connected yet distinct. This episode is about the nature of criticism, while that episode was more about what constitutes “real art” (and the answer is anything). I’m sure that this episode was inspired by that one to some degree, but I also think it was inspired by the real experiences of the writers and such working in the entertainment industry. And not in a “getting back at the critics” way, that’s just asinine.
“The Googly Artist” was much better than I remembered, but it still wasn’t very great. I was just kind of bored throughout most of it, other than some funny and enjoyable moments here and there. There were also a few Patrick scenes I didn’t like. But other than that, this episode is decent and harmless.
Episode Tier: Okay
Episode Score: 6.8/10